Some musings on things

Published on

These four pokies are a part of my origin story, so for better or worse I simply can’t peel my eyes off their goings on.  


I looked at these four gaming trusts in August 2022 and raised a complaint specifically about Dragon.  This complaint widened to include these four.  I believe its ongoing. So while those tasked with regulation go about their jobs, the pokies and community groups they fund continue to go about theirs.  I am uncertain whether these entities are part of Operation Indago which is currently unfolding.  I do hope the story emerges - and I can't help but wonder if I am the "Interested Onlooker" as described in the article.  


I’ve done my usual process: download their grant disclosures, clean up the data and sense check.  The analysis below looks at the financial year end (rather than Granted's calendar y/e). What I do not do with these guys is categorise by type of activity: most the interesting stuff is at the micro entity level.  I did find something quite off with Rano’s disclosure for the first part of this calendar year.  I checked it with Granted.govt.nz’s disclosure and took a degree of comfort that it seemed likely they simply misreported some grants in the first half reporting.  With the charities I rely on publicly available information, generally from Charities, Google, and now a bit of AI who kindly helps me drill through a bunch of websites.  


Looking at these four entities Grant distributions over the years we can see growth has bounced back from 2025’s drop, increasing to (just) an all time high in the 2026 financial year.  

Image description


This increase will be in part driven by an increase in the number of venues under management: in 2017 they had 17 venues and 269 machines: by 30 June 2026 they had 40 venues and 634 machines.  The four also have a skew for Auckland / Waikato region. If we look at the calendar year 2025 (as that’s how I manage the venue data) they lost five venues (which includes the infamous Edinburgh Castle) and gained eight venues. 


I thought you might be interested in the top twenty community organisations that have been granted funding in the last financial year, along with the number of grants, and the date they were registered as an entity.  You can see 20 organisations are getting 40.2% of the total grants by value from these pokies.   Note that I am not saying there is anything untoward with these grants.  However there are a few with very thin governance, and very high numbers of grants, that makes me wonder what is going on here. After all, Blue Sky was the funder of Angel Children's Education which (finally) got deregistered after some Stuff investigations.  Blue Sky may not have understood what was happening with Angel although if not then it suggests some lapses in judgement.  Our hope is that they have learned from this as stewards of community funding.

Charity Name

Dollar Value of Grants

Number of Grants

Date of Registration

Indian Association (Manukau) New Zealand Inc

$250,000

3 

15-12-81

Heritage Foundation

$281,203 

30 

17-10-22

New Zealand Shadow Puppet Art Troupe Incorporated

$284,937 

11 

13-11-19

Univision Community Trust

$304,760 

12

19-01-15

Sporthub Community Trust

$309,810 

16

07-12-23

Caring Hearts Foundation Incorporated

$315,578 

11

10-07-23

Breast Cancer Foundation NZ

$322,250 

3

30-06-08

New Zealand Drom-Don-Ba Buddhist Society

$322,274 

27 

02-12-19

SBS Sports & Cultural Club Inc

$340,267 

31 

16-12-19

Asian Help and Education Charitable Trust

$352,515 

12 

08-06-17

Happy Valley Women and Children's Foundation

$385,030 

20 

20-10-22

Supreme Sikh Society of New Zealand

$407,710 

21 

30-06-08

Wushu Development of New Zealand Trust Board

$416,953 

22 

25-07-24

New Zealand Multiculture and Arts Exchange Centre (was New Zealand Chinese Culture and Arts Exchange Centre)

$430,245 

19 

07-09-17

Next Era Sports (New Zealand Child and Youth Education Trust)

$432,348 

15 

19-11-18

Asian Community Engagement Trust (was Natural Environment Defence Foundation)

$450,782

26 


08-07-20

Inspired Families Foundational Trust

$468,564 

30 

13-04-18

New Zealand Sikh Community Tauranga Trust

$633,200 

8 

19-07-12

New Zealand Sports and Community Development Trust

$859,458 

39 

20-09-23

New Zealand Culture & Media Group Limited

$2,284,156 

53 

27-04-21

Other

$14,633,910

1,952

 

Grand Total

$24,485,952

2,361

 

What is interesting here?  A media company that received $2.3m in grants in one year from 53 separate grants?  At 4.4 grants per month that is a lot of applications.  Looking at Granted.govt.nz data for 2025 (which to be fair isn’t 100% clean but I’ve tried to spruce my copy up a little), they were the 7th highest funded entity out of ALL pokie funded grantseekers, achieved a 99% funding rate AND were never declined a grant.  If we look at the accounts of New Zealand Culture & Media Group Ltd, we can see that 94% of the revenue comes from grants (Blue Sky, Milestone and Rano).  Rano’s 2021 accounts disclose a related-party connection involving New Zealand Culture & Media Group and the management company behind Rano. I have previously raised concerns about aspects of this funding, although I cannot confirm whether DIA has assessed this particular relationship or reached any conclusion about it. The existence of a related-party connection does not, in itself, establish that the funding was improper but the funding rate is striking and, in combination with the disclosed related-party connection, raises questions about how applications were assessed and how potential conflicts of interest were managed.

Image description

The second most funded entity, at $859k in 39 grants (so, 3.25 grants per month!) is effectively an Auckland based community gym where the community subsidy (ie, the pokie funding) is effectively $1313 PER SESSION.  


I’m left scratching my head over Inspired Families Foundational Trust: three trustees and the Chair is an employee.  $468k this last year from 30 grants.  According to their accounts they did much the same this year as the year before: service deliverables are pretty much the same: including the typo.  In the past eight years they have received $4.9m in 285 separate grants from these pokies.


And Asian Community Engagement Trust.  They got $450k in 26 grants.  Its publicly available records raise governance questions that warrant closer examination. The records I reviewed appear to show one trustee, while the trust deed I consulted specifies a minimum of two. 


In the past two years Wish Foundation have received $465k in 39 grants.  Starting in 2024 with two trustees, I couldn't locate the organisation on the Charities Register (but found them on NZBN), so I haven't been able to use that register to verify its current status or review its charity filings.


I’ve also looked at groups in the Top 50 funded list, and view that by year.  Some significant changes:


Lucky Clover Trust: its gone.  In the past seven years they have received $4.1m from these four pokies, in an eye watering 294 grants.  Their latest set of published accounts (2025) suggests they are winding up operations.  It will be interesting to see what happens with the almost $250k worth of assets that the trust owns.  In 2025 they paid $194k in rent for (presumably) their venue at 2163 Great North Road in Avondale.  


We’ve also lost New Life Charitable Trust.  They have now deregistered although still do have a website.  Since 2018 they have received $2.6m in 261 separate grants (that’s an average number of grants of 32 per annum). 


I am saddened to see the deregistration of Sports Development Foundation New Zealand.  Between 2019 and 2022 this entity received over $1.3m in 121 different grants.  Their charitable purpose boiled down to take kids to Snowplanet.  In 2021 they had a registered address at 211 Richardson Road, an address shared by Richardson’s pub (a pokie venuer) for which they paid $78k in rent in their financial year ended March 2021.  


If anyone is interested in having a look at the database I’ve pulled together please let me know.  Its all publicly available data but just assembled in a manner that makes it easier to interrogate.  I’d love to know more about connections between funded entities and venues: I do have a full up to date database on who owns which venues: under law venues cannot have a say in where grant money goes.  


I write about this stuff as I believe that we need to understand where funding comes from, where it goes, and how it gets there.  These groups gave $24.5m into our communities last financial year via 2,361 grants.  In the greater scheme of things its rounding, but for many organisations surviving and doing great mahi it’s a lot of money.  I've come to believe that we, NZ Inc, need some greater oversight of how that money is granted to communities.  These pokies have considerable stewardship over community funding at a time when many groups are starved for funding. Love to talk with you if you think this is at all interesting, and if you want to dive into the data a bit more than happy to do so. Check out my website http://www.delfi.co.nz/

Published on
Picture

So this bombshell happened - a venue and a CEO's home raided by DIA (30 Sept 2026).  I’m watching on the sidelines with my popcorn like some sort of voyeur waiting for the next action here.  A comment by the parent company might be interesting. Crickets (as at publication of this piece).   I have no insight as to what DIA were looking for with this action.  For the record I did complain to DIA in October 2022 about this entity.  My complaint was around their grants practices, in that they seem to give a lot of grants to some relatively new organisations. However  the raid could be related to some more back office activities as per this article.  There was a note in their 2025 accounts of an issue, and it seems unlikely a venue would be raided for issues around grants. I guess time will tell.  


With this entity its important to understand that they are 100% owned by Canterbury West Coast Air Rescue Services – the charity which raises money for the private business who runs Canterbury’s Rescue Helicopters. Regardless of the outcomes of DIA's actions, to me it raises more questions about the reputational risk of marrying a pokie who have been investigated in the past with one of Canterbury's most loved Not for Profits.  


Sitting in my To Be Done was a blog on some thoughts around system change (or, possibly a more click-worthy headline: how to save $1.5m from the grant making ecosystem without actually doing much).  That’s now up.   Below is a dive into their grant distributions to end June 2026.  This is an update to the last review in 2024.  In 2026, they look to have given away $20.1m, up $2.2m from the previous year.  If we look at ARS from an ecosystem view, they are the sixth largest pokie by grants, giving away 5.4% of total pokie grants in calendar year 2025.  As at 30 June 2026 they have 30 venues, picking up one in Auckland off Bluesky this year.


Below is a chart looking at where the money goes.  You would think the name on the tin gives a hint as to where the grants go.  Well, no.  In 2026 Sport gets 46% of the total funding, while Air Rescue Services received 38%. Despite operating in the North Island, none of the North Island helicopter rescue services get anything (although according to Granted.govt.nz 2022 - 2025 data Hawkes' Bay's were the only ones to ask).   Note Education, which got a grand 2% of available funding in 2026, often does use these grants for sport, but without further disclosure on the purpose of the grant its tricky to classify.

Picture
This chart is quite interesting: it sure illustrates the COVID dip in 2021.  At the time Air Rescue only had 7.7% of their machines in Auckland, so were not as exposed as others to the Auckland lockdowns. 

I do have some concerns over the grants to the parent entity for both Canterbury West Coast Air Rescue Trust and New Zealand Flying Doctor Trust.  This money, $7.5m in 2026, flows through to a private business which operates the service.  The point is: how do we, as a community, know that the service is keeping a lid on costs.  Here is where benchmarking would be awesome: indeed I have managed to pull it off in the past but I came up short this time due to differing information from the various entities around the country who do this work.  So sorry. 

Sport deserves a wee dive.  I have looked at the top ten sports in terms of total dollars over the last twelve years (because – why not).  What is readily apparent to anyone is the huge yellow blob and how that’s driven most of the growth in sports grants over the eleven years.  That yellow blob is Football.  The amount of grants given to footie in twelve years by this outfit has grown by around 790%.   Cricket has gone backwards by 24% (which to be fair could be driven by this).  Netball is actually up 32%, albeit off a very small base.  Horseracing fell off a cliff, down to $18k in 2025, but recovered in 2026 thanks in large part to a $59k grant to Kaikoura Trotting Club.  Which is curious seeing there are no ARS venues in Kaikoura. 

Picture

Some people have written on the huge reliance on pokie money for football (including me), and at the grass roots we see an erosion of volunteering and a growth in “jobs” for supposedly amateur players.  One club magically generates $1,576 PER MEMBER from pokies (not this pokie).  I strongly believe that peak bodies need to be a little more realistic about these sorts of spends, and as beneficiaries of such largesse we, as citizens, need to be a little more sceptical about the benefits that such organisations expound.   


Lets look at the top fifteen entities getting grants in the past three years.  Below is a table showing the sum of grants given in the financial year, along with the total number of grants given.  Those gluttons for punishment (aka regular readers) know that I see some concern when a pokie gives a large number of grants to a single entity. We have three years under review: some of these organisations are basically getting a grant a month from this outfit.  Those of you applying for grants should pick up the phone and find out how these grantseekers are so successful - and how they manage the paperwork!  

Entity
2024
2025
2026
TOTAL Sum
TOTAL Count
Canty West Coast Air Rescue Trust
$3,344,647
$3,197,972
$4,249,038
$10,791,657
63
New Zealand Flying Doctor Trust
$3,552,222
$2,919,325
$3,242,000
$9,713,547
38
Nelson Suburbs Football Club Inc
$296,323
$457,254
$437,765
$1,191,342
39
Cashmere Technical Football Club
$239,032
$345,453
$574,293
$1,158,778
24
John Walker Find Your Field of Dreams Foundation
$90,387
$412,606
$488,839
$991,832
26
Dewey Center Foundation
$270,857
$272,900
$306,657
$850,414
28
Canty Regional Basketball Foundation
$305,491
$213,154
$249,204
$767,849
30
Jasmine Arts & Cultural Charitable Trust
$207,368
$240,097
$262,153
$709,618
17
Sport Education Community & Cultural Foundation
$236,881
$218,405
$186,000
$641,286
32
Birkenhead United Assn Football & Sports Club
$149,365
$226,721
$265,111
$641,197
31
Theatre Royal Charitable Trust
$201,536
$221.070
$210,551
$633,157
3
Fencibles United FC
$233,391
$202,572
$195,337
$631,300
27
Miramar Rangers Assn Football Club
$208,172
$197,238
$224,862
$630,272
34
Hokitika Community Trust
$177,102
$201,980
$228,063
$607,144
4
Lower Hutt City AFC
$193,425
$193,272
$228,063
$562,697
32
Other
$8,323,328
$8,411,459
$8,852,450
25,587,238
2,782
Grand Total
$18,029,526
$17,931,479
$20,148,322
$56,109,327
3,210

The comments from last time stand:  not much change but some levels of grant making that are a little eyebrow raising.  You can read some of that here, but that Nelson Suburbs Football Club has been subject to a complaint as have a few of the above.  Dewey Center Foundation too is interesting: registering as a charity in 2021 this pokie is its only funder.  And Dewey is in the same address block as one of the ARS venues.  I also wonder about Sport Education Community and Cultural Foundation,  which registered as a charity in 2019.  The accounts are simple: in and out.  It could be that ARS should be applauded for supporting new organisations.  But I'm inherently distrustful of most things so I'd have a good look at this.  And as for football making up 6 of the top 15 entities..... well


I write about this stuff as believe that as need to understand where funding comes from, where it goes, and how it gets there.  These pokies have considerable stewardship over community funding.  As a citizenry we allow both those supplying money and those asking for money to operate, and as a community we need to ensure we have oversight over the organisations they choose to fund: are they operating efficiently?  Are they leveraging best practice?   Love to talk with you if you think this is at all interesting, and if you want to dive into the data a bit more than happy to do so. Check out my website http://www.delfi.co.nz/